The Social Security program has been a source of progress for elderly Americans since its inception during the Great Depression in the 1930s. Over time it has grown increasingly complex and complicated, and it is easy to want to fix it quickly. A recently proposed Republican-led solution to the Social Security crisis, however, is short-sighted and fails to take into account the long-term consequences of such action. This plan, officially put forth by an anonymous Republican group, features drastic reforms. Benefits and tax burdens would be adjusted to be based on an individual's income, with those earning high incomes paying more. These changes would equate to a massive overhaul of the current system, as traditional principles like the “first-come, first-served” rule would be compromised. Changes of this magnitude would cause serious disruption and dissatisfaction among lower-income senior citizens, who would bear the brunt of the burden. In addition, the higher taxes would incentivize younger generations to shift their competitive focus away from Social Security, while the system’s longer-term sustainability would be highly uncertain. The Biden administration has thankfully rejected this notion, recognizing its likely implications. The White House seeks to make Social Security more equitable, expand benefits to those on the brink of poverty, and increase incentives for younger workers to contribute. These proposed adjustments are more incremental and could feasibly be achieved over time. Rather than radical, across-the-board shift, the Biden administration is seeking a holistic approach. This sensible and methodical plan leaves the door open to more nuanced reforms that could make Social Security more prosperous and equitable without compromising those who are already receiving benefits. In conclusion, the values of balance and equitable progress must be kept in mind when discussing how to fix Social Security. A drastic overhaul of the system may temporarily alleviate certain issues, but at the expense of others. The proposed Republican plan fails to recognize this and falls short in creating a prosperous future for all Americans. Fortunately, the Biden plan keeps the best interests of all involved at its heart, fulfilling the promise of Social Security.